Goodbye to the Geeks, and thoughts about a changed community

In the spring of 2008, I signed up to participate in a new “blogging challenge” organized by Dewey, the blogger behind The Hidden Side of a Leaf. In just over a year of blogging, Dewey had already emerged as a leader within the book-blogging community, and that community was her focus. 

“My main focus in blogging is community. I want to share my love for books with other bloggers, hear what they think of what they’re reading, and have lots of bookish fun. My non-review blog activities…are all meant to build community.”

Dewey had already launched the monthly Bookworms Carnival and the semi-annual 24-Hour Readathon when she started up the activity she called Weekly Geeks. The challenge would involve a weekly “assignment” – a question, a task, a theme – to be completed and posted on the Geeks’ individual blogs and linked up at the main assignment post. Visiting other Geeks’ posts for that week was part of the assignment as well, which is where Dewey’s community-building focus kicked in. Bloggers could participate every week or only when the assignment appealed to them – it was intended to be casual, and new participants were always welcome.

Dewey’s community was stunned on November 25, 2008, when her husband posted an announcement on her blog that she had died. Our shock and sense of loss drew us together, and many of us wanted to see her community-building activities live on. In early 2009, I became part of the team that set up a dedicated blog to continue Weekly Geeks.

Since then, I’ve been a behind-the-scenes organizer, a sometime participant in the assignments, a periodic poster of the link round-ups that concluded each assignment on the WG blog…and, earlier this summer, one vote in the difficult decision to bring this blogging challenge to a close. Participation had dwindled notably, particularly in the last few months, and that seemed like an indicator that the time had come

I tend to think that most memes have a life cycle, and after nearly three and a half years, Weekly Geeks has reached the end of a pretty long – and mostly good – run. I even wonder whether Dewey herself might have ended it earlier. The book-blogging community has been through a lot of changes since she left us; it’s both exploded in size and fragmented into ever-more-specialized niches. While annual events like the upcoming Book Blogger Appreciation Week and Armchair BEA do bring large numbers of us together to share and celebrate what we do, there are times when it’s very difficult to see us as one single “book-blogger community” any more.

And there are times I’m not sure that’s a bad thing. The whole community may be too much for one individual blogger to navigate, but within that whole, most of us manage to find our tribes, and we may find community in multiple places. I suspect that if Dewey were still with us, she’d be doing the same.

Many, many book blogs have come along since late 2008, and while some are already gone, a lot have stuck around…and they’ve never known a book-blogging community that included Dewey. Her blog archives have been taken down, so there’s no way they can get to know her now, either; and with the departure of Weekly Geeks, the original Dewey’s 24-Hour Readathon is her last remaining contribution to us (mark your calendars now for October 22!).

I’m glad Dewey was part of my book-blogging community, and that I’ve had the chance play a small part in keeping her community spirit going.

Wendy has posted a fine, bittersweet farewell to Weekly Geeks at its dedicated blog – please do check it out, and you’re welcome to join us in saying goodbye. 

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,358 other subscribers

Spring ahead, look back: 1st-Quarter Reading Reflections (Weekly Geeks 2011-12)

Spring ahead, look back: 1st-Quarter Reading Reflections (Weekly Geeks 2011-12)

Despite the fact that I’m part of the Weekly Geeks blog team (I do recaps for the site every few weeks), I’m a rather inconsistent Weekly Geeks participant. But this week I’m joining in, as Wendy presents us with a change-of-(reading)-seasons opportunity to take stock: Spring has sprung…the flowers are coming up, baby animals are being born, everything is green and new. Many of us are spring-cleaning or organizing, rethinking and pondering changes…and so I […]

Weekly Geeks’ 10 Things, plus Top 10 Book-Blogging Things!

Weekly Geeks’ 10 Things, plus Top 10 Book-Blogging Things!

The current Weekly Geeks theme revisits one of Dewey’s original topics for the meme: Ten Things About Books and YOU. Here are mine: The current population of TBR Purgatory is 326. I give up book-buying for Lent every year, and this year it’s been surprisingly easy to stick to it. For one thing, I’m getting better about wish-listing books so I won’t forget I’m interested in them, but I think the bigger factor is that I’m […]

A (Weekly) Geeky Friday Foto – and by the way, it’s Delurking Day!

A (Weekly) Geeky Friday Foto – and by the way, it’s Delurking Day!

I’m not a consistent Weekly Geek these days, but the first assignment of 2011 is a fun one: This week, for a Geeky assignment, how about a picture? A self portrait of sorts. I think it would be fun if you all took a picture of yourself (or have someone help you most likely) reading your current book (so we can see what it is) in your favorite reading spot. Then post it! It can […]

The Book of Guilty Pleasures (Weekly Geeks 2010-40)

The Book of Guilty Pleasures (Weekly Geeks 2010-40)

#fullpost { display: inline; } This week, Wendy asked Weekly Geeks to ‘fess up to our less-than-lofty reading pleasures: Recently NPR aired a Guilty Pleasures episode where writers talked about the books they loved but were embarrassed to be seen reading. It got me thinking about all those books I love but don’t necessarily want other people to know I love them. Given that the holiday season is filled with eating the foods we love […]

Reading Plans for 2011 (Weekly Geeks/Sunday Salon on Monday)

Reading Plans for 2011 (Weekly Geeks/Sunday Salon on Monday)

It’s that time of year…and I had planned to talk about it in this week’s Sunday Salon, but I didn’t get a chance to write one. However, when Weekly Geeks posted it as this week’s topic, I decided I’d make my response a special belated Salon post as well. Becky asked: Do you plan on participating in any reading challenges in 2011? Are you planning on hosting any reading challenges? Are there any challenges you […]

Shoulda Read It Sooner! (Weekly Geeks 2010-35)

Shoulda Read It Sooner! (Weekly Geeks 2010-35)

#fullpost { display: inline; } I call it “TBR Purgatory” for a reason – books come in and languish for an indeterminate amount of time before I decide their fate. If they arrive with a due date – publication or review-tour commitment – they’ll get out sooner. Some – granted, not all that many – arrive in hardcover and are still unread when the paperback hits bookstores. And occasionally, when one is finally sprung from […]

Sunday Salon/Weekly Geeks: Readathon plans, and other items on the reading agenda

Sunday Salon/Weekly Geeks: Readathon plans, and other items on the reading agenda

I don’t have a theme for this Sunday’s Salon – I’m a bit random this week. HELD OVER – Banned Books Week: After reading Laurie Halse Anderson’s Speak, I’ve decided to stretch out Banned Books Week a little longer and pull out two books I’d set aside for my failed Shelf Discovery Challenge. Forever… by Judy Blume and A Wrinkle in Time by Madeleine L’Engle are very different from each other, but they’ve both been […]

Books from Birth (Weekly Geeks 2010-29)

Books from Birth (Weekly Geeks 2010-29)

It’s been many weeks since I’ve been a Weekly Geek, but this week’s theme from Wendy appealed to me: (This week’s) Weekly Geeks is about examining a book (or books) which were published in your birth decade. Tell us about a book that came out in the decade you were born which you either loved or hated. Is is relevant to today? Is it a classic, or could it be? Give us a mini-review, or […]

Weekly Geeks 2010-23: The Tale of the Trailer

Weekly Geeks 2010-23: The Tale of the Trailer

This week, Weekly Geeks are considering the newest trend in book marketing: the book trailer. Bernadette says: In the last year or two a new entity has arisen in the publishing world: the book trailer. Apparently every self-respecting book has to have one these days so it seemed a good time to have a chat about them. Feel free to answer as many (or as few) of these questions as you like. Do you watch […]

Wishing and Waiting: The Wishlist (Weekly Geeks 2010-20)

Wishing and Waiting: The Wishlist (Weekly Geeks 2010-20)

This week, Becky asked Weekly Geeks about the infamous, ever-popular Wishlist: Is your wishlist as big as your TBR pile? What books are topping your list? Are there any new releases that you are counting down the days for? Share a handful of titles and be sure to share why you want to get your hands on these books! And if another blogger is responsible for that book being on your wishlist, consider sharing a […]

Weekly Weekend Post-Amazing Library Books…huh?

Weekly Weekend Post-Amazing Library Books…huh?

When Worlds Collide: Since the current Weekend Assignment topic is book-related, I’m combining it with this week’s Weekly Geeks response. Weekend Assignment #318: Library Books: Recently, it was discovered that George Washington had forgotten to return some books he had checked out of his local library. They were only 221 years late, mind you, but late all the same. How about you? Have you ever checked out a library book and forgot to return it? […]

Commenting Commentary (Weekly Geeks 2010-7)

Commenting Commentary (Weekly Geeks 2010-7)

The current Weekly Geeks topic is one dear to the hearts of most bloggers, and one that I obsess over to a ridiculous degree – COMMENTS! Well, to be fair, I obsess a lot more about getting them than giving them – I don’t think I do so badly in the latter department, if I say so myself. It’s also rather timely, since as you may have seen, I recently installed a new commenting system […]

Book Bloggers’ Top 10 of 2009 (Weekly Geeks 2009-43)

Book Bloggers’ Top 10 of 2009 (Weekly Geeks 2009-43)

(Well, I wasn’t sure if I’d have a post up today, but what do you know? Here’s one after all!) I hadn’t expected to start thinking about my end-of-the-year book choices quite yet, but Weekly Geeks is a little bit ahead of me: This is a guest post by Jackie of Literary Escapism who has graciously offered to organize the Book Blogger Top 10 again this year. Welcome to the Weekly Geeks Book Bloggers Top […]

Tools of the (Blogging) Trade (Weekly Geeks 2009-40)

Tools of the (Blogging) Trade (Weekly Geeks 2009-40)

I didn’t get the opportunity to post my response to last week’s Weekly Geeks query, but since there wasn’t a new one for this week – WG took the week off to observe Dewey’s 24-Hour Readathon this past Saturday – I’m squeezing it in before the next theme goes up this coming weekend! Last week, Ruth asked about Tools of the Trade: Book blogging, as a concept, is essentially pretty simple: If you have Internet […]