Respecting the right to choose

Don’t get the wrong idea – that title’s not a reference to the abortion issue. Not going there.

A blog post in On Balance spurred some thoughts on the ongoing conversation (argument? debate? discussion? knock-down drag-out?) regarding the choices of women with children to stay at home with them or be employed. Along the lines of a comment I made in a post a few days ago, this is a “choice” that has to be seen in one’s socioeconomic context – there are many, many women who don’t have it. If they’re single parents or have partners whose income just doesn’t stretch far enough to support a family, they will most likely be working for a paycheck and making the necessary accommodations for their children’s care and well-being in their absence (at least, we hope they’re making those accommodations, but that would be another place I’m not going today).

The thing is, if I understand accurately, one of the goals of the feminist revolution was to give us all access to more options, including the more traditional ones concerning caretaking of our families and homes.

I know that many SAHMs feel that they are making the best choice for their families, and hopefully for themselves as well, but many employed moms would say the same. One of the arguments made in The Feminine Mistake (second link below) is that women shortchange their own financial security – both short- and long-term – by a choice that effectively puts others first, and if their domestic situation were to change they could be seriously impaired. And it could change – divorce, death, and disability don’t just happen to other people.

As for me, I’ve always been pretty sure I wasn’t temperamentally suited for stay-at-home motherhood, and I really admire my friends who have undertaken it. Given that, the fact that I’ve been employed for most of my son’s life was at least partly a decision to count my own needs, but there’s no denying my family benefited financially (and I would argue in other ways as well, since it was better for me personally). And then my domestic situation did change, and my years building my career experience allowed me to relocate and support myself on my own without much agony. Notwithstanding the fact that my stepkids are both school-age and only with their dad and me part-time, I wouldn’t stop working now, and my employment helps my new family too.

Especially if we’re even the slightest bit insecure about any of our choices – and who’s not, in the big scheme of things and considering all the alternatives? – we do tend to feel comforted and validated by those who are going the same way we are, and may feel defensive about and challenged by those who aren’t, and it seems to me that this underlies a lot of this “mommy wars” stuff (and yes, I won’t argue that the media certainly underlies most of it.)

The Mommy War Machine –

The Feminine Mistake – Leslie Bennetts – Mommy Books – New York Times

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,318 other subscribers

Just finished: “Julie and Julia”

Julie and Julia: My Year of Cooking Dangerously, Julie Powell (paperback)original hardcover title: Julie and Julia: 365 Days, 524 Recipes, 1 Tiny Apartment Kitchenfrom From Publishers WeeklyPowell became an Internet celebrity with her 2004 blog chronicling her yearlong odyssey of cooking every recipe in Julia Child’s Mastering the Art of French Cooking. A frustrated secretary in New York City, Powell embarked on “the Julie/Julia project” to find a sense of direction, and both the […]

The Festival of Books is here!

This weekend at UCLA, it’s the LA Times Festival of Books! No Rock Bottom Remainders this year, but we still enjoyed the browsing earlier today. The weather was sunnier and warmer this year than last, and seemed to bring the crowds out early. I had wanted to participate in the giant crossword puzzles again, but as it turned out we didn’t see any. The exhibitor whose booth is don’t-miss for us is Pennyworth Books. (I […]

On the changing times

One of the blogs I keep up with his Leslie Morgan Steiner’s “On Balance” blog through the Washington Post’s website This recent post put me in mind of conversations I’ve had with friends, and my husband, about how it’s not like it was when we were kids anymore. Every generation of parents has probably had that thought, but it means different things in different times. On Balance blog post – Leslie Morgan Steiner En […]

A change is coming

If I’m going to try to get in the habit of updating this blog regularly, I need to start posting more often, and shorter, so I need to stop doing my “reading” posts in a monthly-update format. Effective with my next one, when I finish Julie and Julia, each book review will get a post of its very own. Then I won’t be playing catch-up all the time. And I’m going on the record with […]


An unexpected substitute dog-sitter has emerged from a source we’d never have predicted. The stepkids’ mom, TallGuy’s ex, has offered to keep Princess Fuzzybutt during our trip, due to Mom-in-law’s broken leg/foot…and we’re thisclose to taking her up on it, although we haven’t officially done so. SDKate is pretty excited about having her step-dog with her for the entire week – good thing, since she’ll probably be doing most of the caretaking. We honestly never […]

The best laid plans

So here it is, two weeks before we leave for Tennessee, and I really should be working more than I am today. And as if there weren’t enough things to worry about, we get to add one more – Mom-in-law took a fall and will have her leg in a cast for several weeks, so she can’t drive and probably won’t be walking so well either – and she’s our designated dogsitter. Either TallGuy and […]

April’s reading so far…

Waiting, Ha JinFrom From Publishers WeeklyJin’s quiet but absorbing second novel (after In the Pond) captures the poignant dilemma of an ordinary man who misses the best opportunities in his life simply by trying to do his duty as defined first by his traditional Chinese parents and later by the Communist Party. Reflecting the changes in Chinese communism from the ’60s to the ’80s, the novel focuses on Lin Kong, a military doctor who […]

Not really “Marching” on…

March 2007 Love and Other Impossible Pursuits, Ayelet WaldmanFrom From Publishers Weekly How a five-year-old manages to make the adults in his life hew to the love he holds for them is the sweet treat in this honest, brutal, bitterly funny slice of life. When Emelia’s day-old daughter, Isabel, succumbs to SIDS, her own life stalls. She can’t work; she can’t sleep; Central Park, once her personal secret garden, now is a minefield of […]