librarything change

LibraryThings Have Changed: I Still Love You, LT, But It’s Not The Same

My love for LibraryThing has been well-documented here in the past. While the flame still burns, things have changed between us.

I still appreciate all that LT has done for me, don’t get me wrong. I got a paid, lifetime LibraryThing membership in 2008 to keep track of all the books I owned, whether I’d read them or not. Having my LibraryThing collection on my phone has saved me more than once from buying a book I already had. My preference for LT’s capabilities was only reinforced during the year or two I tried to maintain my account there in sync with one at Goodreads. (I learned my lesson and quit my two-timing ways.) And when I remembered to cross-reference reviews from the blog, it was a handy substitute for a review index.

But all relationships are prone to shifts over the course of time, and mine with LT is no different. Most of the changes in how I use LibraryThing correlate with changes in how I acquire books.

The Things I Keep From LibraryThing

When I started buying ebooks, I waffled over whether to include them in my LibraryThing collections. I didn’t really need them there for tracking what I owned–they all lived in apps where I could easily look them up. In the end, I decided I’d only catalog them in LibraryThing after I’d read them. When I started listening to audiobooks with Audible, I followed the same practice. This means my TBR collections live in several different places–it’s not always convenient, but it mostly works.

I’m an active book blogger/reviewer who has lacked a local bookstore since Borders closed. The books on my shelves are more likely to come from publishers rather than through purchases. However, I discovered during my big book purge last summer that I’m more likely to keep books I buy than books I get “for review consideration” and never consider. I removed stacks of unread ARCs from my house and dozens of titles from my LibraryThing catalog last year. That led me to change my methods for handling review copies. Unless I specifically requested a title, I don’t catalog it until I’m about to read it. Books that I don’t intend to read go straight to the “donate” shelf in the garage. There’s no record that they were ever here.

It’s Not You, LT, It’s Me

I moved the blog to WordPress last winter. The Ultimate Book Blogger plugin has  review-indexing capabilities that meet my needs better than LT’s. And that’s turned out to be very useful. The biggest change I’ve made since the book purge involves a whole category of books that I don’t log into LibraryThing at all, ever.

When I opened my LT account, all of my books were mine–-I’d either bought them or been given them–and that was why I needed to keep track of them. But last summer, for the first time in years, I got myself a library card…and I have been using it. I have yet to check out a print book, but I’ve almost always got active holds on audiobooks and ebooks. The library has become my go-to for books I want to read soon but not immediately, and for books I want to read but am not sure I need to own. LibraryThing only finds out about my library books when I like one of them enough to buy a keeper copy and catalog it. (It has no idea it doesn’t have custody of all my book reviews since this time last year.)

I was on a break from paid reviewing until a few weeks ago, I’ve only been in bookstores a couple of times this year, and I’ve been reading library books. I spent a few hours earlier this week getting my LibraryThing catalog up-to-date, and if I hadn’t gone to BEA in May, the process would have gone even quicker than it did. I’m glad it’s done, though. Things may have changed between us, but I have no intention of breaking up with LibraryThing.

What system(s) do you use to catalog and track your books? Has the way you use them changed over time?

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,318 other subscribers


  1. I’m a two timer – I use both LT and GR but I never remove books from my inventory, even when I get rid of them. I don’t catalog e-books or audios until I read them and usually only on GR then. I like the end of the year stats they provide so I try to keep up with what I read on there.

    1. LT’s collections and tagging are a better fit with the way I organize my books than GR shelves, which is a big reason I went back. I’m glad to know I’m alone in not cataloging the ebooks and audios until I read them :-).

  2. I have a handwritten list of things read. I’m on my third volume now. Then there’s my book blog for longer thoughts about some of the books. I ready upwards of 400 books a year and post 365 or 6 reviews a year, so not EVERYTHING gets covered. Then there’s GR where I track when I read a book and where I got it from through different “shelves.” Finally there’s LT which I purchased a life time membership too when Amazon bought GR in case I found GR too repugnant to work with. I know LT is thinking of physical spaces of books but I still treat it more as a when read, rather then a where shelved, type catalog. Once upon a time, I also had my own home built SQL based catalog of books but I haven’t touched that thing in about four years (ironically since going to library school!)