Book Talk: *Small Town Sinners*, by Melissa Walker


Small Town Sinners
Melissa Walker (Twitter) (Facebook)
Bloomsbury USA Children’s (2011), Hardcover (ISBN 1599905272 / 9781599905273)
Fiction (YA), 288 pages
Source: ARC from publisher (pub date July 2011)
Reason for reading: Faith and Fiction Roundtable discussion

Opening lines: “‘Take the wheel,’ says Starla Joy, sticking the grape lollipop she’s been working on into her mouth. She doesn’t even wait to see if I’ve followed her instructions – she just lets go and strips down, pulling off her light cotton sweater to reveal a bright red tank top dotted with white hearts.

“I lunge across the front seat to make sure her old truck stays straight. A little dust kicks up as we skim the edge of the road.

“‘Starla Joy!’ I shout. ‘I don’t even have my license yet.”

Book description, from the publisher’s website: Lacey Anne Byer is a perennial good girl and lifelong member of the House of Enlightenment, the Evangelical church in her small town. With her driver’s license in hand and the chance to try out for a lead role in Hell House, her church’s annual haunted house of sin, Lacey’s junior year is looking promising. But when a cute new stranger comes to town, something begins to stir inside her. Ty Davis doesn’t know the sweet, shy Lacey Anne Byer everyone else does. With Ty, Lacey could reinvent herself. As her feelings for Ty make Lacey test her boundaries, events surrounding Hell House make her question her religion.

Comments: If you’ve been reading here for awhile, you may be aware that I’m quite intrigued by evangelical Christianity. It’s a worldview quite different from my own – challenging for me to understand, and all too easy to judge – but one that ten years of living in the Bible Belt gave me some exposure to and curiosity about. You may not be aware that I have deep, (probably) irrational suspicion of small towns. Some of that may also be attributed to the Bible Belt; a good chunk of it probably comes from reading a lot of “dark-heart-of-suburbia” fiction. Those elements come together in Melissa Walker’s young-adult novel Small Town Sinners, and made me approach this Faith & Fiction Roundtable selection cautiously.

Sixteen-year-old Lacey Anne Byer’s dad is an assistant pastor at the small-town, charismatic-evangelical House of Enlightenment Church. They’ve had the answers to every question Lacey’s ever had about life and the world so far, and it’s never occurred to her to have follow-up questions – or to seek answers anywhere else. On the verge of entering her junior year of high school, her biggest question concerns what role she’ll land in Hell House, the church’s twist on a Halloween haunted house in which “sinful choices” are dramatized, complete with fake blood, devils, and literally hellish consequences, in the interest of saving souls; it’s their biggest annual spiritual-outreach project. This is the first year Lacey will be old enough to audition, and she’s after the role of “Abortion Girl.” But when a not-so-new boy moves into their town, Lacey’s got something else to focus on. Not only is Ty good-looking and nice, he has questions of his own, and they make Lacey wonder if there might be different, more complex answers than the ones her church and family have been giving her.

My cautious approach to this novel turned out to be unnecessary. Despite the church-centered storyline, Small Town Sinners isn’t terribly preachy, and I appreciated that. I also appreciated that while Melissa Walker has come up with a story in which the characters could have easily been drawn in one-dimensional black and white, she hasn’t done that. Her engaging, church-centered small-town teens aren’t goody-goodies, and their worldview is conveyed believably and respectfully. Meanwhile, the new kid in town isn’t a bad-boy rebel; he’s simply a boy with a different way of thinking – and in its way, in a setting like this, that can be equally threatening, and Walker accounts for that too. One more thing I appreciated is that she gives consideration to the reality that one may question a particular set of teachings about God separately from questioning one’s personal faith in God. This is YA fiction for a mature-minded reader, which happens to be my favorite kind.

Late adolescence is a natural time for questioning the beliefs one has grown up with, and I personally believe such questioning should be encouraged, not stifled. (Heck, I’m still doing it, which is one reason I’m part of this year’s F&F Roundtable in the first place!) I’m inclined to suspect that, by allowing the teenage characters in Small Town Sinners to question and grow and begin to operate within shades of gray, Melissa Walker feels the same way.

Rating: 4/5
Other reviews, via the Book Blogs Search Engine

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,358 other subscribers

What the Hell (House)? Discussing *Small Town Sinners* (Faith & Fiction Roundtable)

What the Hell (House)? Discussing *Small Town Sinners* (Faith & Fiction Roundtable)

Melissa Walker’s YA novel Small Town Sinners (review to be posted on Monday) is the subject of the Faith & Fiction Roundtable’s current book discussion. The novel is focused on a group of teen members of the House of Enlightenment Evangelical church in the small town of West River as they prepare for their annual Hell House presentation/spiritual outreach project, and centered on Lacey Anne Byer, daughter of the assistant pastor. If you’ve never encountered […]

A Discussion for *Leibowitz* (Faith and Fiction Roundtable)

A Discussion for *Leibowitz* (Faith and Fiction Roundtable)

The Faith and Fiction Roundtable’s third book of 2011 was the science-fiction classic A Canticle for Leibowitz by Walter M. Miller Jr. (reviewed here last week). Wait – a “science-fiction classic” for the Faith and Fiction Roundtable? Science and religion do not have to be opposing forces, although history has shown that they often are. They both offer ways to confront the world’s most complex questions, and the conflicts between them usually arise from a […]

The question remains: What good IS God? (Faith and Fiction Roundtable discussion)

The question remains: What good IS God? (Faith and Fiction Roundtable discussion)

“What good is God?” is a pretty big question, and as is the case with most such questions, my feeling is that it has multiple, complex answers…well beyond the scope of this collection of Philip Yancey’s essays and speeches (which I reviewed earlier this week). Yancey seems to realize the magnitude of the question himself, and acknowledges that the focus of most of the pieces here is a little more specific: “What good is God […]

Faith ‘n’ Fiction Book Talk: *What Good is God?*, by Philip Yancey

Faith ‘n’ Fiction Book Talk: *What Good is God?*, by Philip Yancey

What Good Is God?: In Search of a Faith That Matters  Philip Yancey Hachette/FaithWords (2010), Hardcover (ISBN 0446559857 / 9780446559850) Nonfiction (Religion/Christianity), 304 pages Source: Purchased e-book (Kindle format: ASIN B003YFIVGI) Reason for Reading: April 2011 Faith ‘n’ Fiction Roundtable discussion Opening Lines (from the Prologue): “In late November 2008, my wife and I were completing a tour of India sponsored by my publisher. I had spoken on themes from my books in five cities, […]

F’n’F Roundtable #1: Talking about *Certain Women*

F’n’F Roundtable #1: Talking about *Certain Women*

Members of the Faith and Fiction Roundtable – a reading and discussion group that I talked about earlier this week – are discussing our first read of 2011 today; if you’ve also read it, or have thoughts on the themes it brings up, we’d love to have you join in on any or all of our blogs: My Friend Amy Linus’s Blanket Tinasbookreviews Bookjourney Roving Reads Books and Movies Book Addiction Word Lily Ignorant Historian […]

I Believe in Questions; or, Why I Joined the Faith and Fiction Roundtable

I Believe in Questions; or, Why I Joined the Faith and Fiction Roundtable

I was honestly a bit surprised when my application to join the 2011 Faith and Fiction Roundtable was accepted. After all, Amy has heard me call myself a heathen. But she’s also heard me – sometimes, still – call myself a Catholic, although it’s been a while since I’ve been active in the Church where I was raised. However, I’ve found that you can take the girl out of the Church but you can’t take […]