Disclosure: I received a hardcover copy of this book for review from the publisher, via TLC Book Tours, as part of a tour to promote its publication in paperback (now available in stores). *Purchasing links in this review go through my Amazon Associates account.
American Rust: A Novel
Philipp Meyer
Spiegel & Grau (2009), Hardcover (ISBN 0385527519 / 9780385527514)
Fiction, 384 pages
Opening Lines: “Isaac’s mother was dead five years but he hadn’t stopped thinking about her. He lived alone in the house with the old man, twenty, small for his age, easily mistaken for a boy. Late morning and he walked quickly through the woods toward town–a small thin figure with a backpack, trying hard to keep out of sight. He’d taken four thousand dollars from the old man’s desk; Stolen, he corrected himself.”
Left alone to care for his aging father after his mother commits suicide and his sister escapes to Yale, Isaac English longs for a life beyond his hometown. But when he finally sets out to leave for good, accompanied by his temperamental best friend, former high school football star Billy Poe, they are caught up in a terrible act of violence that changes their lives forever.
American Rust takes us into the contemporary American heartland at a moment of profound unrest and uncertainty about the future.
Comments: There are places in this country that have been permanently changed by the recession – not the current one, or the tech-bubble one, but the one from about thirty years ago. That was when the heavy manufacturing that had been the source of American economic strength for so long began to crumble. Jobs left, and didn’t come back; and to find jobs and make new lives, many people found that they had to leave too. But others stayed – sometimes by their own choice, sometimes because they felt they had no other choice. The story Philipp Meyer tells in American Rust concerns all of them.
Lee English got out of Buell, Pennsylvania on a scholarship to Yale, and sealed a new place for herself by marrying a trust-fund baby. Her brilliant younger brother, Isaac, set aside his own academic ambitions to stay with their disabled father, until his feelings of frustration and under-appreciation fueled him to steal some cash from his dad and slip away, planning to hop trains until he made it to Berkeley, California. Isaac’s unlikely best friend, Billy Poe, had blown off the opportunity to play college football and didn’t seem interested in going anywhere, but Isaac decided to try to convince him to tag along anyway. An unexpected encounter on their way out of town sends Isaac off on his own, makes Billy’s prospects cloudier than ever, and brings Lee back home.
Using these three characters as narrators, as well as Billy’s mother Grace and police chief Bud Harris, Meyer covers a brief but eventful period in their lives, but he also takes a deeper look at the conditions that surround and affect them. He vividly evokes a sense of place – a place that keeps a hold on its people through their collective past, despite the fact that it no longer has much in the way of a future to offer them.
American Rust is Phillip Meyer’s first novel, and it’s an ambitious one. At times, I felt that he may have tried to pack too much into it, and I grew a bit frustrated with that later in the book, but for the most part, I think he did it effectively and well. The story didn’t grab me from the first page, but it did pull me in before too long, and then I found myself wrapped up in it. I usually like stories told from multiple perspectives, and I thought Meyer made each character’s voice unique – although I did have to get used to the stream-of-consciousness style he used in writing their inner monologues, which didn’t always clearly set them off from the third-person narration he employed for the story as a whole. I would have liked to see a couple of the characters developed more (and perhaps less of others), but a reader’s interests don’t always dovetail perfectly with the writer’s, and I usually feel that when I’m engaged enough to care about that aspect of the novel, the writer is doing a good job. The mood of the novel is fairly – and appropriately – bleak, but the writing is evocative.
This isn’t a feel-good novel, but American Rust is a thought-provoking and memorable story, and I’ll be interested in seeing what its author does next.
*Buy American Rust at Amazon.com
Tuesday, January 12th: The Blue Stocking Society
Monday, January 18th: Literary Feline
Tuesday, January 19th: Book Club Classics!
Wednesday, January 20th: A Circle of Books
Thursday, January 21st: One Person’s Journey Through a World of Books
Tuesday, January 26th: Luxury Reading
Thursday, January 28th: Ready When You Are, CB
Tuesday, February 2nd: Rough Edges
Thursday, February 4th: Bibliophile by the Sea
Monday, February 8th: Bibliofreak
Tuesday, February 9th: Becky’s Book Reviews
Friday, February 12th: Beth Fish Reads
Tuesday, February 16th: Books on the Brain
Thursday, February 18th: So Many Precious Books, So Little Time
Monday, February 22nd: Lit and Life
Thursday, February 25th: Steph and Tony Investigate
It sounds like Meyer has a lot of potential as an author. The book sounds interesting – I have a feeling my husband would like it.
I hear "stream of consciousness" and I get SCARED and have memories of struggling through Faulkner! But seriously this book is definitely on my TBR list!
Kathy (Bermudaonion) – But if your husband reads it, will he guest-post a review :-)?
I do think this is a pretty strong first novel, though.
Kathleen – Oh, don't worry. It's nowhere near Faulkner (and I know exactly what you mean) :-). I'll be interested in your take on it.
I'm reading this one next week. Looks like it will be interesting.
Lisa – I'll look forward to reading your take on it!
Thank you for your insightful review, Florinda. I think I had the hardest time settling into Isaac's chapters, especially in the beginning and yet I found his journey among the most interesting. I would like to have spent more time with the sheriff and Billy's mom, I think.
Wendy (Literary Feline) – I honestly thought your review was more insightful than mine; this was a bit of a challenge to write, actually. You have a good point about Isaac's chapters, since they seemed to contain the most internal monologue. I would have liked more of Grace and Bud as well, I think.