The question remains: What good IS God? (Faith and Fiction Roundtable discussion)

“What good is God?” is a pretty big question, and as is the case with most such questions, my feeling is that it has multiple, complex answers…well beyond the scope of this collection of Philip Yancey’s essays and speeches (which I reviewed earlier this week).

Yancey seems to realize the magnitude of the question himself, and acknowledges that the focus of most of the pieces here is a little more specific: “What good is God when disaster strikes anyway, and belief doesn’t protect us?” I suspect that after a week of storms that have caused 300 deaths and millions of dollars’ worth of damage, that’s a particular resonant question in the Bible Belt right about now.

I’m not sure belief is supposed to protect us, like a magic shield. Rather, I think it offers a way to process events we’re not protected from – a refuge, a community, a framework for moving forward. In addressing groups who have been victims of traumatic events – the Virginia Tech shootings, the terrorist attacks in Mumbai – or forced underground by prosecution – Christian communities in China and the Middle East – I think Yancey recognizes this. The book’s subtitle is “In Search of a Faith That Matters,” and my impression is that the kind of belief I describe is the sort that “matters” in the contexts he presents here.

Because this was a collection of talks given to a variety of audiences, I don’t think it addressed what a “faith that matters” is supposed to look like – and I appreciated that. I think that approach was also influenced by the way in which Philip Yancey came to his own faith. He was brought up in a fundamentalist church and graduated from a Bible college, but his worldview – and understanding of God in the world – expanded as he reached adulthood. He takes a pretty strong stand against what he calls “legalism,” or the excessive focus on “rules” about the “proper” way to believe and express one’s faith that often seems to lead to “my Christianity is better than your Christianity” competitiveness – not especially Christian behavior, in my opinion, and Yancey seems to recognize that such rules are not really the point of a faith that matters.

I don’t think Philip Yancey actually answers the question posed in the title of this book – not in the book, at least. I’m not sure the travels and people he writes about here are finding the “faith that matters” the subtitle alludes to. And personally, I’m not bothered by either of these matters’ remaining unresolved – as I’ve said before, I’m more interested in the questioning and the searching than in actually getting answers sometimes.

Members of the Faith and Fiction Roundtable are discussing our second read of 2011 today; if you’ve also read it, or have thoughts on the themes it brings up, we’d love to have you join in on any or all of our blogs:

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,420 other subscribers

So long, soaps! It’s been (un)real…

So long, soaps! It’s been (un)real…

Image by kevindooley via Flickr If I still watched the soaps, I’d feel this development more than I do, but it still makes me feel sad and a bit displaced to know that ABC is cancelling All My Children and One Life to Live. It’s been over twenty years since I watched them much, but starting much too young and through my post-college years, I had a pretty serious soap-opera habit. It started in my […]

The Art of Giving

The Art of Giving

I received this original artwork this past weekend as a belated birthday gift from my mother-in-law. “Happily Ever Now,” original collage by Jason Mraz, 2011 She personally delivered the gift to me on Saturday when she came to spend Easter with us; the artist had personally delivered it to her just a day or two earlier. He’s a friend and neighbor of hers who created this original collage to be auctioned in a fundraiser organized […]

Faith ‘n’ Fiction Book Talk: *What Good is God?*, by Philip Yancey

Faith ‘n’ Fiction Book Talk: *What Good is God?*, by Philip Yancey

What Good Is God?: In Search of a Faith That Matters  Philip Yancey Hachette/FaithWords (2010), Hardcover (ISBN 0446559857 / 9780446559850) Nonfiction (Religion/Christianity), 304 pages Source: Purchased e-book (Kindle format: ASIN B003YFIVGI) Reason for Reading: April 2011 Faith ‘n’ Fiction Roundtable discussion Opening Lines (from the Prologue): “In late November 2008, my wife and I were completing a tour of India sponsored by my publisher. I had spoken on themes from my books in five cities, […]

Sunday Salon: Countdown to BEA (Anxiety)!

Sunday Salon: Countdown to BEA (Anxiety)!

  One month from today is the first day of BEA! This will be my first trip to Book Expo America, and I find myself wavering between eager excitement and anxiety with a touch of crankiness as I anticipate it. This is actually not an unusual reaction for me as I prepare for a conference, and at this stage, the anxiety – which makes me cranky – seems to be running a little ahead of […]

Week-End Review – and pictures, too!

Week-End Review – and pictures, too!

There’s more “review” this week-end than I’ve managed to gather up in quite a while – plus a little editorializing – so let’s jump right in! Good News/Bad News, “Bookstores I Have Known” Department:Good news, via Shelf Awareness: “Buffalo Street Books, the Ithaca, N.Y., bookstore that closed last month and has reorganized as a coop (Shelf Awareness, March 7, 2011), is opening this coming Saturday, according to the Ithaca Journal. The store has more than […]

Randomness: Four Things for Thursday

Randomness: Four Things for Thursday

No, this is not the “Four Things” meme (not today, anyway). I actually have a proper Week-End Review to post tomorrow, so here are some Thursday Tidbits to mention. Sign-ups are open for the second year of Armchair BEA! Over 200 people have already signed up, and even though this virtual conference has no capacity limits, what are you waiting for? If you’re not going to be in New York City next month for Book Expo America […]

It's all relative; or, focusing on a family

It's all relative; or, focusing on a family

There are stories I don’t tell here because they really aren’t mine to tell, but sometimes I find myself thinking about them anyway, and that’s what led me down this particular path…in search of an angle from which there might be a story I could claim and tell. After almost 27 years as an only child, yesterday my son just became a big brother to a baby sister. (NOT from me – I would have […]

Monday Moment: It’s not Easter yet, but I bought books!

Monday Moment: It’s not Easter yet, but I bought books!

As I do almost every year, I gave up buying books for Lent. Some years I stick to it pretty well, and some years I don’t; some years I take way too much advantage of the “Sunday loophole.” (Count the days between Ash Wednesday and Easter; they’ll add up to more than 40 if you count Sundays. Therefore, “Sundays don’t count” in keeping a Lenten vow. So said my mom.) This year had been a […]

Sunday Salon: Change of (Reading) Habits, and some news!

Sunday Salon: Change of (Reading) Habits, and some news!

  Last weekend, I set aside the book I was reading on my Kindle for this month’s Faith ‘n’ Fiction Roundtable in order to tackle some “fresh” reading for the 24-Hour Readathon. That went well; I started and finished two books that day. However, I still have not finished the FnFRt reading! However, I’ve read enough to participate in the group discussion of Philip Yancey’s What Good Is God?: In Search of a Faith That […]

Week-End Review: Does it count if I haven’t been around all week?

Week-End Review: Does it count if I haven’t been around all week?

The following recap of my week is brought to you by Friday Fill-Ins 1. For me, it was one busy week! Between work, physical-therapy appointments, preparing for the panel I’m moderating at the Book Blogger Convention next month (!), and making some necessary changes to my eating and exercise habits, I’ve gotten very little reading done since last weekend’s Readathon and almost no blogging. You may have noticed. Or maybe not. But it may be […]

Book Talk: *The Wilder Life*, by Wendy McClure

Book Talk: *The Wilder Life*, by Wendy McClure

The Wilder Life: My Adventures in the Lost World of Little House on the Prairie Wendy McClure Riverhead Hardcover (2011) (ISBN 1594487804 / 9781594487804) Nonfiction (memoir/literature), 352 pages Source: ARC from publisher (pub date 4/14/11) Reason for reading: Review copy; 24-Hour Readathon, Spring 2011 Opening Lines: “I was born in 1867 in a log cabin in Wisconsin and maybe you were, too. We lived with our family in the Big Woods, and then we all […]

Sunday Salon: The End of the Readathon

Sunday Salon: The End of the Readathon

Today’s Sunday Salon will wrap up my participation in yesterday’s 24-Hour Readathon with my completion of the End-of-Event Survey: 1. Which hour was most daunting for you? I flagged around Hour 11 or so; after I finished my cheerleading shift, it was a bit challenging to get back into reading mode and I kept fighting off the urge to take a nap! Hours 18-21 (11 PM-1:45 AM local time) went surprisingly well, thanks to a […]

Halfway There: Spring Readathon Update #2

Well, it’s past halfway, I’m afraid, and I’m late with the Mid-Event Survey, but I didn’t want to post an update until I actually finished a book! 1. What are you reading right now? I just finished The Wilder Life: My Adventures in the Lost World of Little House on the Prairie by Wendy McClure. I think I’ll switch to fiction next: Girl in Translation by Jean Kwok.  2. How many books have you read so far? Just one, […]

Start Me Up: Spring Readathon Update #1

Start Me Up: Spring Readathon Update #1

It’s 5 AM Pacific time – opening bell for the Spring 2011 24-Hour Readathon! I have never lasted through the entire 24 hours, and I don’t expect things to be any different this time, but it’s always fun to see just how long I make it! I will be spending most of the day – and into the night – here: But that chair’s in the same room as the TV, so there will probably […]