Sunday Salon: (Banned) Books I’ve Read

The Sunday 
Salon.com

I’m very much in favor of the freedom to read what one chooses to read – and in order to make those choices well, one needs access to the full range of choices. I also believe in the freedom to choose not to read something. But I believe those rights belong to the individual and not to any institution (with an exception, perhaps, for parents of young children regarding what those children read in their own homes). I do not support censorship. I don’t believe in delegating my right to decide what I can and can’t read to anyone else. I have the tools to make those decisions for myself, and I believe we all have the right to those tools.

Having said that, I don’t make a point of seeking out and reading banned or censored books just because they’re banned. In some cases, the attempt to censor a book will actually pique my interest in it; it’s the lure of the forbidden. (And some authors are well aware of that lure.) But I also know there are themes and topics that just don’t appeal to me, and quality of writing notwithstanding, if I choose not to read a particular book, that will be the reason why, not because it’s been challenged by some educational or morality police. That choice should remain mine – and yours.

In honor of Banned Books Week, I thought I’d do a little inventory. With the help of LibraryThing’s catalog of works tagged “banned books,” I identified those in the top 150 that I’ve read at some point in my life – some I currently own, and some I read years ago (or at least prior to blogging).


Image credit

There aren’t all that many commonalities among the books in this list, thematically. They vary in their objective literary merit, and if it weren’t for the fact that they’ve been banned or challenged, there would probably be nothing especially memorable about some of them. However, they’ve all been challenged because they pose a challenge – to ideas about religion, politics, morality and ethics, and the structure and habits of society. And if a society – or an individual – means to grow, it’s necessary to challenge those ideas.

And sometimes challenged books just make some people squeamish, and for that reason, they don’t think anyone should read them. A story about a teenage girl who silences herself after she is raped by an acquaintance is clearly  not dealing with a comfortable subject, but does that mean that Laurie Halse Anderson’s YA novel Speak should be banned…as pornography? It’s not the first YA novel about a teenage girl who gets raped by an acquaintance (am I the only one who remembers Are You In the House Alone? by Richard Peck from the late 70’s, my actual YA years?)…and like it or not, that is, quite unfortunately, not a farfetched or fantasy-based plot. I haven’t yet read Speak, but I did buy a copy of it this week. And if it is banned, I’ll be proud to add it to my inventory of Banned Books I’ve Read.

Banned or not, I will be carrying whatever I’m reading during this Banned Books Week in this bookbag, which I bought at Comic-Con this past summer:

You can get one of your own at the Unshelved Store.

Are you reading banned books this week?

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 2,358 other subscribers